Public or Private: Where should I get my breast cancer treatment in T&T

Breast cancer patient with oncologist

I know the visceral reaction you might have when you think of getting healthcare treatment in the public system in Trinidad and Tobago. The reports of hours long waits in the A&E is enough to make anybody nervous, but when it comes to cancer care, you might want to take a second look. Private healthcare is a dream, and I’m sure if you could, you would, but should you? Let me share the pros and cons of private vs public health care for cancer in Trinidad and Tobago and I’ll share with you my approach to treatment.

Cost

I think the biggest determining factor for anyone seeking treatment for breast cancer is how much it costs. When I was first diagnosed, I was anxious to get started with treatment and looked at getting at least my first chemo treatment done privately. When I realised it would be in excess of 50k TTD, I quickly redirected myself to the St. James Medical Complex, ha! In all, the overall cost for cancer treatment can run you up to or even past a million dollars TTD, depending on what you get done.  If your treatment plan is similar to mine i.e. chemo, double mastectomy, breast reconstruction, implants, radiation and hormone therapy you are looking at a boatload of money. Not to mention the endless tests you’ll probably do in-between. Even with insurance these costs can be prohibitive to many if you seek care privately. When it comes to cost, free will always beats paid, so the public healthcare system wins this one

Speed

Regarding speed, there isn’t even a question that the private sector wins. Speed of service delivery, especially when your life hangs in the balance, is invaluable and could make all the difference in choosing where you access treatment. For every day your test results take to come back to you, cancer goes untreated in your body. Its enough to give anyone anxiety. In the public sector, while tests are done you will wait a long time to get results. In private, if they say one week, its one week. That alone brings you a measure of comfort.

Efficiency

Efficiency depends on a few things, but in this case I want to focus on how well systems work in the private vs public sector healthcare. On this one I’m a little torn because there are areas where the private sector beats public hands down, like speed of service delivery, and physical settings but the public sector doctors are ultra resourceful as they have to serve many with not-so-many resources, and they are also very thorough. Ultimately, I think the public wins this round of battle.

Bed-side manner

The relationship you have with your doctors and nurses is very important. While all healthcare professionals, public and private, have a duty of care to ensure that patients are taken care of completely and in accordance with their wishes, meeting the extra warm ones who take the time to explain and chat with you is priceless. I’ve met warm and cold professionals in both private and public sector and sometimes it comes down to the individual. It’s hard to pick a winner here, so I’ll call this one a draw.

Business Priority

Private hospitals, like every other business, is in existence to make a profit. Sometimes it’s difficult to imagine someone prioritizing money over your life, but when it comes down to it, if you can’t continue to afford a service, that service will cease. When your insurance refuses to cover that second CT scan, or echocardiogram or PET scan in the same year, you either pay out of pocket or go without it. Because the priority of the public sector is to ensure the best healthcare and not profits, you will always referred for tests when you need them whether you can afford them or not. If you need a CT, a PET, an echo, bloodwork, a diet plan, physiotherapy, it’s only a referral away. Doctors here focus on getting you better or making you the most comfortable with the time you have left. The public wins this battle easily.

When I sought treatment, I blended my approach. I did my tests privately to take advantage of the speed and I used those results to help my doctors treat me publicly. I started at Pink Hibiscus Breast Specialists then was referred to the St. James Medical Sciences Complex. This is the approach I would advise anyone to take. Breast cancer treatment is a marathon and not a sprint, therefore you should save money where you can, because something will always come up. You just never know. Above all, I think we ought to be so thankful for the resources we have access to in Trinidad & Tobago. In many countries, if you have no insurance, you have no chance. In others, there aren’t even systems, resources or national programmes to guide citizens on how or where to get treatment. Yes, you have to wait a long time, but what a few hours to save your life? Just make the most of the time while you wait. Whatever approach you choose, I keep you in my prayers and wish healing upon your life.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *